Showing posts with label diplomacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label diplomacy. Show all posts

Friday, June 8, 2018

The Very Stable Genius and the runup to G7: It gets worse

Just before departing for Quebec, he throws this into the mix:

President Trump called on allies to reinstate Russia as part of the G7 Friday, deepening a rift over trade policy that spilled out on Twitter just days ahead of the summit in Canada.
And just why does he want to reinstate this country that harasses our planes and ships, meddles in our elections, supports Assad in Syria, and assassinates its ruling regime's own political opposition?

I'm afraid the VSG's signature circular reasoning is not going to be of any help here:

" . . I would recommend — and it’s up to them — but Russia should be in the meeting, it should be a part of it. You know, whether you like it or not, and it may not be politically correct, but we have a world to run and the G-7 — which used to be the G-8, they threw Russia out — they should let Russia come back in because we should have Russia at the negotiating table.” 
And that "We have a world to run" is a telling touch of classic VSG arrogance. Not lead, mind you, but run.

Surreal.

The VSG further strains US alliances

The G7 meeting is happening this seeking, and, in addition to the latest bit of boorishness displayed toward Canada's Pierre Trudeau, the VSG goes into it with. the much-vaunted bromance with France's Macron also now sullied. He's signaling that he may walk out before the whole meeting has taken place. Macron expressed displeasure at this, and the VSG wasted no time responding:


Macron's tweet:


The American President may not mind being isolated, but neither do we mind signing a 6 country agreement if need be. Because these 6 countries represent values, they represent an economic market which has the weight of history behind it and which is now a true international force
The VSG:
 
Even as late as Thursday afternoon, Trump was questioning why he would attend a G7 meeting where he's outnumbered on key issues like trade and climate change. As a series of combative tweets from Macron began emerging late in the day, Trump again raised the prospect of scrubbing all or part of his visit to Canada, asking advisers what the point of attending the summit would be, according to a person familiar with the conversations. 
He was told that canceling the visit entirely would appear like he's shrinking from a fight he proudly began. And with that in his head, Trump told his advisers he'll enter the talks swinging. 
And swing he did on Twitter, responding to Macron's assertion that G7 nations would band together without the US.
"Please tell Prime Minister Trudeau and President Macron that they are charging the U.S. massive tariffs and create non-monetary barriers. The EU trade surplus with the U.S. is $151 Billion, and Canada keeps our farmers and others out. Look forward to seeing them tomorrow," Trump tweeted.


And, through administration staffers, is signaling that he's none too keen on the UK's Teresa May:

Donald Trump has grown frustrated with Theresa May’s “school mistress” tone, allies of the president have told The Telegraph, as it emerged the pair will not hold formal talks at the G7 summit in Canada.
The US president is said to bristle at the Prime Minister’s approach during phone calls, with Mrs May quick to get into policy details rather than wider conversation. 
One senior US diplomat said Mr Trump had expressed annoyance at Mrs May’s frequent demands, which are seen as taking advantage of the UK-US relationship.
If there's one thing we know about the VSG, it's that he quickly gets annoyed with those pesky "details."

The US does indeed have the correct policy toward the climate-change nonsense, but this is hardly the way to go about making that clear to all involved. One can safely assume that the VSG is handling it this way because to stay and discuss it with his peers (although I doubt he'd see them as peers) would entail immersing himself in yet more pesky details.

And just who does he expect to have his back at the summit with Kim once things get more, shall we say, detailed after the initial photo op?

Spin this into 5-D chess, all you slavish devotees.

Thursday, June 7, 2018

And then there's this

In the course of the take-questions-from-the-press portion of his meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe today, the Very Stable Genius said rather forthrightly that he's basically winging it regarding the upcoming Kim summit:

On Thursday, the president showed little concern himself. Speaking to reporters before a White House meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Ave he said: “I don't think I have to prepare very much. It's about attitude. It's about willingness to get things done.”
Allahpundit at Hot Air has done some thought-provoking analysis on the internal dynamics of the Trump national-security team's planning, or lack thereof, for the summit. His pieces are here,  here, and here.  The gist of what he's analyzing is all the talk that Pompeo and Bolton don't get along, that the latter froze the former out of the White House meeting with that North Korean intelligence thug, and that Bolton dropped the "Libyan model" idea into his remarks in order to scuttle or at least dampen the possibilities of a summit. Allahpundit poses a good question for those inclined to embrace that view: Why did Mike Pence reiterate it?

Allahpundit floats the possibility that Bolton concurs with the VSG that not a whole lot of preparation is needed a this point, with all the off-and-back-on status changes (not to mention Giuliani's weird remark about Kim begging on his hands and knees for a reinstatement).

And it gets weirder still. There's talk of a round of golf at Mar-a-Lago. And one frothing-at-the-mouth VSG devotee thinks it's a stroke of 5-D chess:

There’s another possibility. The goals of the summit may be so diminished by now that Bolton has concluded there’s little to prepare for. He wants the NorKs to commit firmly to denuclearlization, to the point where they show up in Singapore with a list of ports the U.S. Navy can use to carry away Kim’s nukes and enrichment infrastructure. Trump has scaled those ambitions way, way back, though, telling reporters last week after the meeting with Kim Yong Chol that the summit would be a “get to know you” session. I think POTUS is now viewing this as essentially a gladhanding opportunity, a chance for him to mount a charm offensive, build a rapport, then let the eggheads take over to hammer out a compromise. He’s spent his entire adult in Manhattan real estate and politics schmoozing shady characters. How hard can it be to schmooze a monster? In fact:
[A]ccording to two administration officials, Trump has also raised the possibility of a leisurely activity and, perhaps, getting in 18 holes with Kim if the two end up getting along.
“He has also discussed [possibly] golfing with Kim,” a senior Trump administration official said…
“I think that would be phenomenal—I think it would be a huge foreign policy win if President Trump got Kim Jong Un on a golf course, especially if he did it at Mar-a-Lago,” Eric Bolling, a close Trump friend and former Fox News star, told The Daily Beast.
I have my doubts that it amounts to grand strategy. That's not something the VSG has ever demonstrated a capacity for, at least to my satisfaction. His modus operandi in foreign-policy matters tends to hew more closely to the kind of clumsiness demonstrated in his most recent phone conversation with Pierre Trudeau. 

Trump's imparting a sort of Bolton-esque tone to some of his statements about the summit, saying denuclearization is a must for any kind of deal.  But LITD is far from convinced that this hard-ass stance being put forth basically in the same breath with Mar-a-Lago talk leaves me skittish rather than giddy.

I understand I could be proven wrong. I just have yet to see signs of genius in the foreign-policy arena from the guy.




It's this kind of stuff

Just about the time you permit yourself to consider that he may have some native diplomatic chops, the Very Stable Genius goes and does something like this:

President Donald Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau had a testy phone call on May 25 over new tariffs imposed by the Trump administration targeting steel and aluminum imports coming from Canada, including one moment during the conversation in which Trump made an erroneous historical reference, sources familiar with the discussion told CNN. 
According to the sources, Trudeau pressed Trump on how he could justify the tariffs as a "national security" issue. In response, Trump quipped to Trudeau, "Didn't you guys burn down the White House?" referring to the War of 1812. 
The problem with Trump's comments to Trudeau is that British troops burned down the White House during the War of 1812. Historians note the British attack on Washington was in retaliation for the American attack on York, Ontario, in territory that eventually became Canada, which was then a British colony.
When asked if the comment was received as a joke, one source on the call said: "To the degree one can ever take what is said as a joke. The impact on Canada and ultimately on workers in the US won't be a laughing matter." 
    The White House declined to comment and the National Security Council did not immediately return a CNN request for comment.
    Let us parse the levels:


    1. That kind of half-bro-humor / half-alpha-male-strutting stuff may be the currency of the realm in the world of Manhattan real estate, but this is international diplomacy.
    2. It's another instance of going out of his way to alienate an ally whose support we'll surely need in dealing with the country with which there are real trade issues - namely, China.
    3. The Left is going to have a hoot over the glaring blurt of historical ignorance for years to come.
    Look, LITD has no special regard for Trudeau. He's a lefty with goofy views on any number of issues. He himself - along with his family - made an extended faux pas out of the recent India visit, going around that country in hokey get-ups intended to patronize their hosts.

    But this is trade. Since a lot of people - maybe you and me - see the national-security claim as a ruse, if the VSG really thinks it's an important reason for tariffs, he owed Trudeau the courtesy of a serious explanation.

    It's going to be interesting to see the slavish devotees spin this one, which they will.
     


    Wednesday, December 28, 2016

    Hopefully, this is as much of a top priority for the new administration as repealing the "A"CA, overturning environmental regs and appointing good judges

    The necessity of squarely addressing Iran's violations of the JCPOA will become apparent sooner, not later:

    The real problem with the Iran deal—despite it being loose, porous, and temporary nature—is that the Iranian government itself has no intention to abide by it. Put aside questions about Iran’s ballistic missile work—Kerry arguably conceded that against the backdrop of last-minute Iranian brinkmanship—and the refusal of Iranian officials to allow inspections of military sites, a red line international inspectors have chosen not to test.
    Iran’s overproduction of heavy water is a violation that has now occurred twice. The international community has allowed Iran to sidestep the violations by exporting its excess heavy water, even if that meant U.S. taxpayers were essentially subsidizing and rewarding Iran’s illegal nuclear activity.
    Now, Behrouz Kamalvandi, the spokesman of the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran, has said Iran will reduce its exports of heavy water even though there is no evidence that Iran will stop producing such large amounts of heavy water. This is worrisome, of course, because heavy water reactors can produce plutonium as a byproduct. The Iranian argument that limitson heavy water are a suggestion and not mandatory will have no traction once Kerry departs the State Department.
    This means that the first Iran crisis of the Trump presidency is looming. Iran will, once again, be in violation of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action. It will now be up to Trump to determine whether he will ignore or rationalize the violation despite his campaign rhetoric or take action. If he follows the process laid out by the agreement, Russia and perhaps China will defend Iran despite the blatancy of Tehran’s violation. That leaves Trump with a choice: stand down and lose face—an action which will do as much harm to U.S. credibility as Obama’s decision not to abide by his own red lines in Syria—or punish Iran unilaterally. If the Iranian press is to be believed, the Islamic Republic has now thrown down the gauntlet and started the countdown to what may be the first diplomatic crisis of the Trump administration.
    It is helpful that the agreement isn't a legally binding treaty. The US Senate didn't ratify anything.


    Saturday, June 4, 2016

    On flimsy resumes, juvenile rantings and a post-America in sharp decline

    I've been thinking about what was billed as a major foreign policy address by Hillionaire. What particularly strikes me is the range of opinion on the right. John Podhoretz and Charles Krauthammer, to name a couple, were surprised at how impressed they were, saying it was downright substantive. Others panned it roundly, calling it thin on both vision and a list of her accomplishments.

    I'd put myself in the latter category. When she started into her brag list, it was clear she had nothing but the weakest of tea to offer. She spoke of negotiating a "climate-change" deal with China. She did nothing of the sort. China doesn't have to lift a finger regarding its carbon output until 2030. She spoke of helping to craft sanctions against Iran. A lot of good those have done. (See post below.) She mentioned her work on behalf of LGBT people around the world. Um, okay.

    Of course, Squirrel-Hair has already responded, and done so with his characteristic bombast. Screaming about how she's a liar.

    I'm afraid we're seeing how the dynamic of the inevitable two-candidate race is going to play out. Hillionaire will make statements and give speeches that don't amount to diddly, but will comport herself with sufficient bearing to allow the media to portray her as statesmanlike, in contrast to the fourth-grade playground-bully antics of S-H. And his Bots will be oblivious to how it's shaping up.

    And, of course, the real prescription for restoring America to its role as the guarantor of a just and humane world order, not to mention its basic domestic safety, will not get an airing.

    It's a certainty that Western civilization is past its peak.

    Friday, August 28, 2015

    With diplomats like ours, why shouldn't the world smell weakness?

    Post-America's UN ambassador Samantha Powers is concerned about our nation's loss of cred on the world stage should Congress 86 the Iran deal:

    First, if the United States rejects this deal, we would instantly isolate ourselves from the countries that spent nearly two years working with American negotiators to hammer out its toughest provisions. Those partners believe that this is a sound deal—with a rigorous set of inspection measures that would allow us to know if Iran is not playing by the rules. And those countries have been very clear that they are not prepared to walk away from this deal to try to secure different terms. So if we walk away, there is no diplomatic door number two. No do over. No rewrite of the deal on the table. We would go from a situation in which Iran is isolated to one in which the United States is isolated. That would not be ideal under any circumstances, but it would be particularly damaging in a context in which Iran continues to pose a profound threat to international peace and security, against which global unity and pressure will be critical. 
    Second, well beyond the consequences vis-a-vis Iran itself, rejecting this deal would likely undermine our ability to use sanctions in other circumstances. At the UN I routinely encounter countries that do not want to impose sanctions or even to enforce those already on the books. The hard-line sanctions skeptics have their own self-interested reasons for opposing sanctions, but they ground their opposition in claims that America uses sanctions to inflict punishment for punishment’s sake. In response, I tell foreign diplomats that sanctions are not an end in themselves, but a means of marrying coercive measures with diplomacy to try to change behavior—whether that behavior threatens international security or inflicts widespread human suffering. And I tell those diplomats that when diplomatic paths seem to emerge, America will pursue them, and we will ease the pressure if the grounds for imposing sanctions are addressed. 
    In the case of Iran, the United States persuaded other countries to apply pressure for a purpose—in order to secure significant, long-term constraints that would cut off all of Iran’s pathways to a nuclear weapon. If we move the goalpost now—arguing, for example, that there should not be sanctions relief until Iran stops supporting terrorist proxies or until it permanently gives up nuclear enrichment for peaceful purposes—we would give detractors a powerful tool to try to obstruct our future efforts on issues unrelated to Iran. Our efforts to reach this deal have affirmed the view of the United States as a tough but principled leader; rejecting it would be read in many quarters as a superpower intent on inflicting pain for its own sake. 


    A few indications of her world view stick out like sore thumbs here. There's her ironclad confidence that sanctions snapback would  would be a snap:

     . . . businesses that had already signed new contracts in Iran . . . would have to phase out their contracts or face penalties for violating sanction

    Then there's her tacit acknowledgement that this deal allows Iran to continue to foment terrorism.

    Then there's her saddening belief that "shared values" rank higher with German, Turkish and Russian businesses - and the governments that give them the green light to sign deals with Tehran - than opportunity for lucrative commerce.

    While . . . soft power is built in many ways, two of its most important sources are the belief among other countries’ leaders and publics that we share similar values, and that America delivers on its commitments.
    Let's look at Russia in particular, since it is a rather unavoidable force among the nation-states that crafted this "deal." Does it really share our values, or believe that America delivers on its commitments?

    The evidence suggests otherwise:

    On September 5, 2014, Russian agents crossed into Estonia and kidnapped an Estonian security official. Last week, after a closed trial, Russia sentenced him to 15 years.


    The reaction? The State Department issued a statement. The NATO secretary-general issued a tweet. Neither did anything. The European Union (reports the Wall Street Journal) said it was too early to discuss any possible action.


    The timing of this brazen violation of NATO territory — two days after President Obama visited Estonia to symbolize America’s commitment to its security — is testimony to Vladimir Putin’s contempt for the American president. He knows Obama will do nothing. Why should he think otherwise?

    Putin breaks the arms embargo to Iran by lifting the hold on selling it S-300 missiles. Obama responds by excusing him, saying it wasn’t technically illegal and adding, with a tip of the hat to Putin’s patience: “I’m frankly surprised that it held this long.”

    Russia mousetraps Obama at the eleventh hour of the Iran negotiations, joining Iran in demanding that the conventional-weapons and ballistic-missile embargos be dropped. Obama caves.

    Putin invades Ukraine, annexes Crimea, breaks two Minsk cease-fire agreements, and erases the Russia–Ukraine border. Obama’s response? Pinprick sanctions, empty threats, and a continuing refusal to supply Ukraine with defensive weaponry, lest he provoke Putin.

    It's extremely difficult to take Powers seriously in light of the actual facts on the ground.

    What most of the world sees is a patsy former superpower that will do nothing to prevent shortsighted opportunists from exploiting a situation that's going to be profitable in the short term, but, beyond that time frame, is going to wind up facilitating an apocalyptic scenario we can scarcely bear to contemplate.

    Tuesday, June 2, 2015

    Meanwhile, as the patty-cake has continued . . .

     . . . this is transpiring.  And the NYT is baffled:

    “Western officials and experts cannot quite figure out why,” notes the Times, despite the fact that UN inspectors have had “almost daily access” to Iranian nuclear facilities. These are the same inspectors we’ll be relying on to detect whether Iran’s cheating once the final deal is in effect. If they can’t tell why a stash of nuclear fuel right under their noses is growing, what don’t they know about projects that Iran has worked harder to conceal?
    As a preface to the news, here’s a suddenly memorable quote from this year’s State of the Union: “Our diplomacy is at work with respect to Iran, where, for the first time in a decade, we’ve halted the progress of its nuclear program and reduced its stockpile of nuclear material.”
    Allahpundit at Hot Air, from whom I've excerpted here, makes the point that the Most Equal Comrade claims the military option is off the table, because all that would do is set back the program - which is all his damn deal would do. 

    Sunday, November 23, 2014

    The Most Equal Comrade goes overseas and embarrasses post-America - today's edition

    The MEC can play patty-cake with the Iranian mullahs, do a reset with Russia, accept a Noam Chomsky book from Hugo Chavez and coddle a Muslim Brotherhood regime in Egypt, but when it comes to those that had been allies when this was the United States of America, he can't conceal his contempt:

    Lost in the shuffle of Obama’s immigration diktat and his sham of a farce of a travesty of a climate agreement with China was his speech about climate change in Canberra, Australia, where Obama went out of his way to insult Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott.  Apparently our embassy personnel in Canberra advised Obama against this course, but naturally Obama knows better.
    Australian newspaper columnist Greg Sheridan reports on the matter in an article that is behind the newspaper’s paywall (but easily gotten around through Google if you want to), so here are the important excerpts from it:
    BARACK  Obama defied the ­advice of his embassy in Canberra to deliver a stinging attack on the Abbott government’s climate policies in Brisbane last weekend.
    The US embassy, under the leadership of ambassador John Berry, advised the President, through his senior staff, not to couch his climate change comments in a way that would be seen as disobliging to the Abbott government, sources have revealed. . .
    It is normal practice when the US President makes an overseas visit that the ambassador in the country he is visiting is consulted about the contents of major speeches. It is unusual, though not unprecedented, for an embassy’s advice to be ignored.

    Because a scientific fiction, being so useful as a took for imposing totalitarian collectivism, is more important than shoring up strategic alliances in a world full of wacko jihadists and unfriendly Communists.

    That's why we call him a Western civilization-hater.

    Wednesday, October 29, 2014

    Because the Israel-hatred goes all the way to the top

    That's why Jen Psaki said this:

    Jen Psaki made it clear that the Obama administration has no interest in trying to find out who made recent inflammatory comments about Israeli Prime Benjamin Netanyahu.
    “Is the administration trying to figure out who made these inappropriate and counter-productive comments?” Reuters reporter Arshad Mohammed asked.
    “No,” Psaki said. “There are anonymous sources in all of your stories every single day. If we spent all of our time focused on that effort we wouldn’t be working on diplomacy.”

    Why would they want to out whoever it was and get that person in trouble when they all think the same thing?


    Wednesday, April 9, 2014

    Secretary Global-Test shreds one of our most important alliances

    Israel is making known its unhappiness with GT's remarks that pretty clearly laid the blame on the collapse of the current round of Palestinian patty-cake on Israel because it was, shall we say, reluctant to release from prison a bunch of jihadists who had been incarcerated for acts of terror in the first place, as well as its insistence that its citizens can build neighborhoods in a particular section of Jerusalem.


    Nice work, GT.



    Monday, March 3, 2014

    The Most Equal Comrade hates the very civilization that spawned him

    He clearly wants to see the only Western nation in the Middle East rendered completely vulnerable to its enemies.

    Ahead of Netanyahu's visit to the US today, the MEC gave an interview to Bloomberg and said that Abbas was a broker in good faith (I wish the interviewer had pressed him on Abbas's outright refusal to recognize the Jewish nature of the Israeli state) and that post-America would not be able to defend Israel unless it gives up Samaria and Judea.

    Of all the countries to blackmail, he picks one of our closest allies:

    The wild logical contradictions in his remarks expose the degree to which the American approach in the Kerry peace talks is to haunt Israel with the dire nightmare it will face should the talks fail; Palestinian rejectionism plays almost no role in the Obaman calculus here.
    The Palestinians, in Obama’s view, do not actually need to make changes; astonishingly, he says, they’re ready for peace. “The Palestinians,” the president says, overlooking every piece of polling data we have about the opinions of the Palestinians, “would still prefer peace. They would still prefer a country of their own that allows them to find a job, send their kids to school, travel overseas, go back and forth to work without feeling as if they are restricted or constrained as a people. And they recognize that Israel is not going anywhere.”
    Ah. So that 2011 poll that says 60 percent of the Palestinians reject a two-state solution is bunk—a poll whose findings have not been  contradicted since. If Palestinians refuse to accept a two-state solution, they do not “recognize that Israel is not going anywhere.” Rather, they are still engaging in a pseudo-national fantasy about Israel’s disappearance or destruction. And they are so eager for peace and coexistence with Israel that they remain the only significant Muslim population that still has a favorable view of suicide bombings, according to a Pew survey.
    “The voices for peace within the Palestinian community will be stronger with a framework agreement,” the president says. But why would the “voices for peace” need to be “stronger” if they reflect the actual views of the Palestinian people? They should be more than strong enough on their own now. Indeed, if they are so strong, we would not be hearing repeated denunciations of the “framework” process from Palestinian negotiators.
    The president’s fantasies about the Palestinians also  involve Mahmoud Abbas, president of the Palestinian Authority. “I think,” he says, “nobody would dispute that whatever disagreements you may have with him, he has proven himself to be somebody who has been committed to nonviolence and diplomatic efforts to resolve this issue.” Nobody would dispute? In 2008, offered a peace deal by then-Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert that involved Abbas actually drawing a new West Bank map giving the Palestinians something between 92 and 95 percent of the territory, Abbas basically fled the table and didn’t return. Granted, he didn’t do what Yasser Arafat did after a similar deal at Camp David in 2000 and begin the second intifada, but this hardly demonstrates a commitment to a diplomatic effort—except for one that fails.
    The fact that abetting the Palestinian quest to end Israel's existence is such a high priority when there are real threats and issues piling up in his in-box makes it clear that he really is a declinist with contempt for the West.



    China, Russia, Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, Nicaragua and North Korea are all taking note of this.  A man with such disdain for his own civilization is a piece of cake to walk right over.

    Tuesday, September 17, 2013

    Because his objectives are crystal-clear, as is his understanding of human nature

    A most insightful profile in the NYT on Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov.  Edifying background on his career as a diplomat and how he acquired his world-affairs savvy, and how he ate Secretary Global-Test's lunch.

    Monday, December 31, 2012

    The latest evidence that the MEC holds the country he presides over in utter disdain

    Have you heard about the State Department advisory group headed by former SecDef William Perry?  I hadn't either, but I'll pay more attention now.  It is recommending that the MEC regime and Russia work out a plan to reduce their respective nuclear arsenals without bothering to craft an actual treaty and present it to Congress for ratification.

    I guess this kind of development is to be expected, given that we now live in a climate in which someone who has taught constitutional law at Georgetown for forty years can get New York Times op-ed space in which to say it's time to jettison that document, which, in his view, has outlived its usefulness and constrains us in an age of unforeseen complexity.

    I don't continue to fight because I'm brimming with confidence about freedom's prospects.  I continue to fight because I couldn't live with myself if I didn't.