Showing posts with label American founding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American founding. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 28, 2020

Tuesday roundup

Richard Reinsch II has a great piece at Law & Liberty entitled "Irving Kristol's Rules for Nihilists." A taste:

Many of us now feel old, detached even, before our time. The beliefs, attitudes, mores that our parents, clergy, coaches, teachers, and other authority figures, almost unconsciously imparted to us, seem increasingly like museum pieces. Should we consign individualism, competitive striving, personal accountability, to say nothing of a belief that we live and act under God and the moral law, to an antiquated, bigoted past? In is the new victim slick and its reduction of the person to gender and race—its symbology sits on your Nike apparel, emblazoned on sporting venues, touted by leading corporations. Out is the fabric of liberty and order, honesty and sobriety, diligence and thrift. The symbology of these virtues may become synonymous with white supremacy, the ontological core of American identity, we are increasingly told. The Smithsonian Museum for African American History and Culture has pedagogical plans on this front.

We confront the following question: “what if the “self” that is “realized” under the conditions of liberal capitalism is a self that despises liberal capitalism, and uses its liberty to subvert and abolish a free society?” This question was asked forty eight years ago by Irving Kristol in his magnificent 1972 lecture “Capitalism, Socialism, and Nihilism,” delivered to the twenty fifth anniversary meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society. Kristol understood well the problems of liberal democratic society when it is detached from metaphysical and spiritual goods. He underscores what he thinks are the tendencies for such an order: a vacuous liberty increasingly perceived as unworthy of defending and the turn to a pathological, if not socialist tinged, notion of the good. The outcome, Kristol feared, would be a sickness leading to death. His insights in this essay clear a path forward during our own sickness in 2020.


One of the speakers at yesterday's America's Frontline Doctors event on the steps of the Supreme Court is a real humdinger:

Immanuel, a pediatrician and a religious minister, has a history of making bizarre claims about medical topics and other issues. She has often claimed that gynecological problems like cysts and endometriosis are in fact caused by people having sex in their dreams with demons and witches. 

She alleges alien DNA is currently used in medical treatments, and that scientists are cooking up a vaccine to prevent people from being religious. And, despite appearing in Washington, D.C. to lobby Congress on Monday, she has said that the government is run in part not by humans but by “reptilians” and other aliens.

Immanuel gave her viral speech on the steps of the Supreme Court at the “White Coat Summit,” a gathering of a handful of doctors who call themselves America’s Frontline Doctors and dispute the medical consensus on the novel coronavirus. The event was organized by the right-wing group Tea Party Patriots, which is backed by wealthy Republican donors.

In her speech, Immanuel alleges that she has successfully treated hundreds of patients with hydroxychloroquine, a controversial treatment Trump has promoted and says he has taken himself. Studies have failed to find proofthat the drug has any benefit in treating COVID-19, and the Food and Drug Administration in June revoked its emergency authorization to use it to treat the deadly virus, saying it hadn’t demonstrated any effect on patients’ mortality prospects.

“Nobody needs to get sick,” Immanuel said. “This virus has a cure.”

The account goes on to say that "[t]oward the end of Immanuel's speech,  the event's organizer and other participants can be seen trying to get the microphone away from her."

Rod Dreher's essays at The American Conservative are always worth one's while. Today's is particularly good. It's about what a poisonous undertaking the 1619 Project is:

In our time, the New York Times journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones has been celebrated as the genius behind the Times‘s 1619 Project, which is an attempt to — in the Times‘s word — “reframe” American history around slavery. No longer should 1776 be considered the year of America’s birth, but rather 1619, the year the first African slaves were brought to the New World. Jones won the Pulitzer Prize this year for her work on the project. It is based on a fundamental historical falsehood — a malicious and destructive one too: that the purpose of America was to preserve slavery.

A number of historians — none of them conservatives — called Jones and her team at the Timesout on this lie (see here for a list of some of the names, and their criticism). This is a lie that could have tremendous consequences. As Princeton historian Sean Wilentz, himself a man of the left, has said:

“To teach children that the American Revolution was fought in part to secure slavery would be giving a fundamental misunderstanding not only of what the American Revolution was all about but what America stood for and has stood for since the Founding.”

But Jones’s lie is politically useful in advancing the identity-politics goals of progressives. Oprah Winfrey and Lionsgate are going to make a series of films and feature television shows based on the 1619 Project. They are changing the cultural memory of Americans, in a way that deceives people about what America was, and is. Nobody can possibly deny that slavery was a terrible stain on this nation, but it is an evil whose existence stood as a rebuke to the Founders’ ideals. It took a Civil War to finally end the malignant institution — but it did end, at the cost of between 600,000 and 750,000 American lives. 

He takes on the ginned-up outrage over Tom Cotton's "necessary evil" remark:

The reason we’re talking about it now is that Sen. Tom Cotton, Republican of Arkansas, is sponsoring legislation that would prohibit the use of federal tax dollars to teach the 1619 Project in American classrooms. Whether or not such legislation is wise is certainly debatable. What’s caused the ruckus is this section from a story in the Arkansas Democrat Gazette:

In the interview, Cotton said the role of slavery can’t be overlooked.

“We have to study the history of slavery and its role and impact on the development of our country because otherwise we can’t understand our country. As the Founding Fathers said, it was the necessary evil upon which the union was built, but the union was built in a way, as Lincoln said, to put slavery on the course to its ultimate extinction,” he said.

Instead of portraying America as “an irredeemably corrupt, rotten and racist country,” the nation should be viewed “as an imperfect and flawed land, but the greatest and noblest country in the history of mankind,” Cotton said.

This is being wildly misconstrued as some sort of justification for slavery. What Cotton is saying simply is that the United States could not have existed if the non-slave states had not agreed to accept the slave states. It was a doomed compromise, a one we eventually had to go to war over, but it launched the country. Cotton is pointing out the tragic nature of the compromise that made America possible as a nation united under the Constitution. He is not defending slavery, which would be as insane morally as it would be politically. He is repeating a similar point that Abraham Lincoln made in an 1855 letter to Joshua Speed, a friend of his who owned slaves:

You ought rather to appreciate how much the great body of the Northern people do crucify their feelings, in order to maintain their loyalty to the Constitution and the Union.

Do you see?
Attorney General William Barr's testimony before the House Judiciary Committee is ongoing even as I write, so it will be some time before takes on the overall arc of his appearance begin coming out, but his opening statement doesn't sugarcoat anything.  

One thing I am getting from real-time observations on Twitter is along these lines:


Jim Jordan, who has built an entire brand around yelling at witnesses and giving them no time to respond, is complaining that Democrats are doing that to Barr.
What's in each party's new COVID-19 relief bill? Some commonalities (direct payments), some differences (liability protection for businesses, schools and health care providers).  
 
 
 


Saturday, July 4, 2020

The LITD 2020 Independence Day post

As longtime readers know, I occasionally express the hope that someday this blog's name will become obsolete, that it won't be so late in the day, that we'll have a fine stretch of sunlight hours before us. Alas, that still eludes us.

It's been years since I could work up anything more than wistfulness on Independence Day. The plain fact is that our nation, as an idea, a geographical place, a collection of people, is badly defiled, perhaps hopelessly so.

Crap about how we've never enjoyed such convenience, comfort, leisure, technological advancement and options for how to live misses the point, which is that America has been getting steadily spiritually sicker for decades.

The turmoil of the present year - the pandemic, the economic collapse, the race-hustling which has been given an opportunity to permeate our society with renewed vigor by some instances of police misbehavior, the nihilistic hatred for our history expressed by the toppling of monuments, the riots, the spike in violent crime, the cesspool that social media has become - can obscure the fact that the rot began setting in years ago.

Exactly when? That's kind of a parlor-game question. A case could be made for pointing to the progressive era of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, when the ideas of Thorstein Veblen, Richard T. Ely, Herbert Croly, Woodrow Wilson, and John Dewey took hold. The common thrust of their thought was that, in an age of industrialization and urbanization, America could no longer rely solely on its founding documents and the ideas that animated them, that the federal government needed to enlist a cadre of experts in matters such as education, health care, transportation and finance to fine-tune the operation of the country. Legislation would merely flesh out the details of the experts' central plans.

A case can also be made for the rise of the New Left in academia. When William Appleman Williams came up with the idea of moral equivalence, that the US sphere of influence and the Soviet empire were basically indistinguishable and that it mattered not which one prevailed on the world stage, it set in motion the impetus that caused the US to lose its resolve in Vietnam, leading to the pathetic scene in April 1975 of the helicopter taking off from the roof of the US embassy in Saigon, people desperately clinging to its runners. It led to the cowardice with which the administration of Columbia University responded to the campus takeover by radicals in the spring of 1968. Now such takeovers are so commonplace as to be yawn-inducing. Indeed, it spurred a whole new way of looking at the entire arc of our history. Howard Zinn's poisonous tome A People's History of the United States began insinuation itself into high school and college classrooms in 1980, paving the way for the similar insinuation by the New York Times' 1619 Project a couple of years ago.

Perhaps the pivotal point was the launch of the movements that insisted that nature's design for human sexuality could be ignored. That, in due course, led to laws that will exact fines and imprisonment for not calling a man a woman if he insists that that's what he is.

So this didn't start with the Green New Deal or the transformation of the Republican Party into a cult of personality built around the most unfit person to ever hold the office of US president.

My point is that it doesn't get any better from one year to the next.

No, I'll eat some hot dogs. That's a tradition at our house. Really good hot dogs, with a casing that snaps when you bite into them, dressed properly, with diced red onion, course-grain mustard and a quality relish. I read the Declaration of Independence to my wife this morning, another tradition around here. We played Stars and Stripes Forever by the United States Marine Band. We're about to go for an invigorating bike ride.

But as far as a feeling welling up inside of me goes, it's one of nostalgia at best.

It is very late in the day in post-America. Sorry for the stark assessment, but sugar-coating the matter would be a disservice to you.

Wednesday, March 11, 2020

Finally, some initiatives to counter that insidious 1619 Project

A reassuring development:

The Bob Woodson Center and Washington Examiner is offering an alternative to The New York Times and Pulitzer Center’s “1619 Project.” Theirs is aptly named “The 1776 Initiative.”
Responses to the 1619 Project are popping up everywhere. Countless conservative scholars have weighed in, both Civil War and founding-era historians have teamed up to cry foul, Hillsdale College is offering an online course to counter the narrative, the Heritage Foundation has compiled a trove of essays titled “1776: A Celebration of America,” and the National Association of Scholars has started a “1620 Project.”
Woodson's project has some heavy hitters among its participants:

The 1776 Initiative is headed by Bob Woodson, a former civil rights activist, head of the National Urban League Department of Criminal Justice, and resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. The 1776 Initiative also has a plethora of well-known and respected contributors, such as syndicated columnist Clarence Page, Shelby Steele of the Hoover Institution, Glenn Loury, professor of economics and social science at Brown University, and many more.
The Woodson Center press release describes the contributors as a “consortium of top black academics, columnists, social service providers, business leaders and clergy from across America who are committed to telling the complete history of America and black Americans from 1776 to present.” 
I like the way the Washington Examiner went about announcing it:


The Washington Examiner announced the 1776 Initiative in honor of famous abolitionist Frederick Douglass’ birthday, saying the contributors share an aversion to the “infantilization of black America or the denial of blacks’ agency throughout their history” and a distaste for “pseudo scholarship” that reduces American history to a history of racism and that consigns black Americans to the permanent status of victim.
I know the Human Rights Commission in the city where I live has the insinuating of the 1619 Project into out local school curriculum on its front burner. If the school board has any integrity, it will insist that 1776 Initiative materials be included wherever 1619 Project content is considered.

Monday, February 3, 2020

Monday roundup

Great Allen Guezlo essay at Public Discourse on reconciling two views of America: creed and culture.

Pete Wehner at The Atlantic on how the GOP has been broken by Trump:

From a certain perspective, their timidity is understandable. They know that to publicly challenge Trump—to call out his ethical transgressions, cruelty, and indecency even as they support his policies—invites impassioned attacks from Trump supporters and, in some cases, a primary challenge. No one likes to be under attack, particularly by the base of one’s own party, and no one wants to lose a job.
Moreover, they will argue, they must defend the president in public so they can have influence in private. They have also convinced themselves that they are essential to the project of repairing the Republican Party post-Trump, and that this requires that they not be viewed as disloyal to Trump while he’s serving as president. “What good does it do to attack Trump?” they will ask. He won’t change his ways, and they will only weaken themselves in the process. (Many of them are happy to attack Trump in private conversations, citing, chapter and verse, things he has said or done that alarm them, showing that they both know better and are playing a cynical game.)
That, at least, is the story they tell themselves. Some of what they say is worth taking into account. But what they don’t tell themselves, probably because it would be too psychologically shattering, is that they have become fully complicit in a corrupt enterprise called the Trump presidency. (Romney is the rare exception.) They are defending actions they know are wrong and that, if they had been done by a Democratic president, they would be outraged by. More than that, they are validating Trump’s approach to politics—the hyper-aggression, the lawlessness, the mendacity, the shamelessness—and therefore guaranteeing imitators. It also happens that their influence on the president is far sm
aller than they tell themselves. They have made concession after concession after concession, justifying each one along the way. Then you look back at the road they’ve traveled, and it’s breathtaking. Donald Trump has changed them far more than they have changed Donald Trump.

Michael Strain, writing at Bloomberg, makes a point, focusing on economic policy, that LITD often makes in a broadly applied way: Yeah, we're facing a binary choice, and both options are rotten. That's especially so if the Dem candidate turns out to be Bernie Sanders.

For a presidential contender who makes her aversion to fossil fuels the centerpiece of her political life, Elizabeth Warren has some eye-opening connections to that industry:

So it’s worth noting that, for years, she and her husband reported modest income from natural-gas royalties in her native state of Oklahoma. Ms. Warren’s financial disclosure filed with the Senate in 2012 included $504 of income from “gas well royalty interests” in Latimer County. The next year it was $203. Drill a little deeper and the facts get even more interesting.
Ms. Warren’s campaign has posted 11 years of her tax returns, which show gas income from at least 2008. That year she filed jointly with her husband, Bruce Mann, who had $872 in royalties from gas wells in Oklahoma. There are smaller amounts—a few hundred dollars—reported over the next several tax returns, before the yearly earnings stop.
You might be thinking that we’re only talking about a few hundred dollars here and there, several years in the past, for someone who is a multimillionaire. What’s the big deal, right? Well, if you read on in the WSJ report, it goes deeper than what’s found on her tax returns. Property records show a 2011 sale of all the oil, gas and mineral rights for some of their property to none other than their own son, Alexander. (Keeping it in the family, I guess.)

The paper trail goes on further, including quite recent events. There’s a 2017 transfer of parcels of property in Hughes County, Oklahoma, including drilling rights, involving her son and three of her brothers. The agreements include the payment of royalties for any recovered resources. And those agreements were slated for three years, so they will still be in effect until at least this summer.

Paul Krause at The Imaginative Conservative says that revisiting Milton's Paradise Lost can broaden our sense of the full meaning of the term eros.

I seriously have not drawn a conclusion yet on this one. Was Nigel Farage's farewell address to the European Parliament, replete with Union Jack flag-waving, hours before Brexit became official, a gratuitous stunt that merely increased the sum total of yay-hoo-ism in the world, or was it the perfect outgoing message to send to Brussels? It sure brought out the pinched-face-schoolteacher in Parliament VP Mairead McGuinness. What do you all think?



 





Wednesday, September 4, 2019

Your absolute must-read for today

At City Journal, Harvey Mansfield offers an essay spurred by this circumstance and this thought:

A conference that I attended recently at the Chateau of Alexis de Tocqueville in Normandy brought me to confront Tocqueville with Donald Trump. I did not see how I as an American, just now, could come to Europe and say nothing about America’s latest choice as president.
He explores a couple of dichotomies that we find particularly pressing in the present moment, but that have always been with us in some form:

  • the particularities that make for a distinct culture in a particular land and the diminishing of those by the advent of global supply chains and international trade in general, or, as Mansfield puts it, "the tension between nation and commerce," and
  • equality and hierarchy
It's one of those pieces the contours of which find their convergence at the end, but it's also full of great money lines. In fact, those money lines, presented in sequence, can give one some idea of those contours and their convergence:

"Tocqueville was a great thinker, a philosopher greater even than his admirers believe, and Trump is great mainly in the amazing extent of his pettiness and willingness to level insults at his rivals. Occasionally, he reaches upward, as in his recent speech at the World War II invasion beaches of Normandy, not far from the Tocqueville Chateau, though he frequently spoils his moments of elevation with a cheap remark."

"In two well-separated passages in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), [Montesquieu, one of Tocqueville's favorite authors] says, first, that 'movable wealth . . . belongs to the whole world, which in this regard comprises but a single state of which all societies are members,' but later, in the context of political laws for a nation, says it is among the right of nations that a “great state” can exclude one 'imbued with foreign maxims' in the royal succession under the principle (set in capital letters) that “the well-being of the people is the supreme law.' Montesquieu adds that 'men care prodigiously for their laws and their customs; these make the felicity of every nation; it is rare for them to be changed without great upsets and great shedding of blood.'"

"A demagogue in the classical sense is one who seeks to be loved indiscriminately, not caring by whom, one eager to move the people as he or they wish, thus an evil endemic to democracy. Trump’s success in gaining the presidency without experience in diplomacy or government reminds us of the essential vulgarity of democracy, for he is not above or against democracy, as is said by his opponents."

"there are many others who never read books, and in a democracy they have votes. And there are, too, plenty of book-reading intellectuals who are disgusted with the display of easy moral superiority that impels political correctness and has come to be called 'virtue-signaling,' one vice Trump manages to avoid."

"Democracy, with its demand for ever-more equality, robs all inequalities, whether of family, piety, race, sex, birth, or especially intelligence, of any pretense of authority to rule. The result is an anarchy of equals, none having authority over anyone else. Yet democracy has need of precisely the expertise that is the source of inequality in authority."

Ironically, says Mansfield, democracy spawns its own aristocracy, and thus breeds an inherent resentment:

"Democracy, with its demand for ever-more equality, robs all inequalities, whether of family, piety, race, sex, birth, or especially intelligence, of any pretense of authority to rule. The result is an anarchy of equals, none having authority over anyone else. Yet democracy has need of precisely the expertise that is the source of inequality in authority."

He points out that the way Trump rolls is rich in irony:

"[Trump's] policy of 'America First' is ambivalent between hawkish bristling and dovish isolation, as if a nation could warn possible enemies without ever having to punish them in case the warning is ignored. He warns enemies so as not to join the company of the Democrats, but refrains from attacking them in order to distinguish his policy from neoconservatism. This potential for inconsistency can easily upset sound policy, but again, it is a failing more democratic than anti-democratic." 

"Trump is accused of authoritarianism, but this is because he is as impulsive, abrupt, and inconsistent as a democratic majority. Like an untaught, unshackled majority, he seeks the advantage of immediacy against time-consuming, obstructive intermediaries, procedures, and legalities that hinder his, or the popular, will."

And soon afterward Mansfield delivers a money line that brings us to the summation of his position:

"The founders of the American nation would not have admired Donald Trump. "

I'll tease you by leaving it to you to read his concluding paragraph, which expands his subject matter to the level of general principle, principle that we would do well to consider deeply.

Thursday, July 4, 2019

The Independence Day post

It comes along just days after what, from a number-of-months standpoint, is the midpoint of the year. It insists on being celebrated outdoors, with grill food, near water, if possible. Fireworks and patriotic music ought to be part of the mix as well.

It's still worth celebrating, even though the sociocultural landscape, as well as the political scene, is bleak. Immutable principles, as is stressed repeatedly at LITD, remain so by definition even if their application is hard to find.

It's interesting that the country from which the colonies had to do their breaking was Britain, given that Britain had more to do with the development of the idea that a society could be established on the principle of maximized freedom than any other nation-state in history. The big leaps forward, such as the Magna Carta, the 1689 Bill of Rights drafted upon the collapse of James II's rule, and the works of John Locke, came from there.

And British society at the time separation fervor was spiking in the colonies was incredibly culturally and intellectually rich. Adam Smith published Wealth of Nations in 1776. Sir Joshua Reynolds, Edmund Burke, David Hume, Samuel Johnson, George Whitefield and John Wesley were all active then.

And George III was in a lot of ways an unlikely tyrant. He was devout in his faith life, a patron of the arts, and interested in the sciences. He really didn't focus on the American colonies a great deal until he was made aware of resistance to the various newly imposed forms of taxation and British disregard for colonial legislative bodies.

But by the 1770s, a few generations had come along in which lots of people had never been "back" to the mother country. The crown and Parliament were something of an abstraction for them.

But what they did have were those British intellectual roots. Collective memory of the milestones in the advance of freedom ran deep.

Tax policy was a top-tier issue for the Founders, as it is again in this age when Bill deBlasio speaks of plenty of money in the wrong hands.

The Virginia Declaration of Rights, drafted weeks before the US Declaration became law, speaks of life, liberty and property as fundamental rights. It's a notion that comes from Locke's Two Treatises of Government. While Jefferson decided to go with the pursuit of happiness as a specifically mentioned right, the conviction that being able to own something was core to all kinds of other freedoms was deeply ingrained in the American character.

Independence Day is a secular holiday, but it rather insists on our refecting upon our blessedness. The thought leaders among the Founders were a diverse lot in many ways. Each brought a particular facet of overall understanding of the nature of freedom and its relationship to order to the table. It led to some sharp disagreements among them. But to consider even cursorily that minds such as those of Ben Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, George Mason, Richard Henry Lee, Alexander Hamiton, John Jay, James Madison, and George Washington found each other and found sufficient common cause to draft the second and third most thunderously powerful documents (after the Holy Bible) in human history is to be awestruck in the most intense degree.

We, of course, have nothing like that today. There may be a handful of minds of the Founders' caliber in various pockets of the current post-American government - even in Congress - but none are in position of real leadership. Those posts have gone to mediocrities, charlatans, lunatics and lovers of tyranny.

And much of the 2019 post-American populace is in the position of bread-and-circuses late-period  Roman Empire citizens. If it can be bothered to contemplate such matters as what is and what cannot by definition be a right, or the relationship between the individual and the state at all, it thinks in terms of  the "right" to be"gender fluid" or the "right" to health care.  And those who may have an ever-so-slightly-deeper understanding of the matter have come to think in terms of measuring national health in terms of gross domestic product, wage growth, and stock-market averages. The yearnings of the human spirit are absent from the discussion.

It's against this backdrop that celebrating Independence Day gains its significance at this time. The principles remain, they are still practiced to some degree in some places in post-America, and we still observe some tradition.

Let's think of it as a day of possibility. It's very Late in the Day, but not completely dark. The best tribute we can pay to those who birthed this unprecedented experiment is to refuse to squander our birthright, no matter how many around us are doing exactly that.

Thursday, July 5, 2018

Recklessly squandering the source of our greatness

This is going to be another of those posts that largely consists of generous excerpts from something I link to. It's that important.

The linked piece is by Heidi Munson and it's at The Resurgent. It is about something that is one of the main themes here at LITD: the question of how much more societal brittleness our nation can withstand.

The statistics would indicate that the continuity of our essential identity is unlikely. Consider this:

We are the anomaly. Except for the state of Massachusetts, America has the longest lasting constitution in the history of the world. In contrast, France has had 16 constitutions since ours has been ratified. Venezuela has had 25, Haiti 23, Ecuador 20. In the last century alone, Russia has had four, and Poland has had seven. Since we haven’t lived through the tumult of revolutions, we take our stability for granted and assume it will last in perpetuity. We are fools if we think that.
Which, of course, begs the question "why."

The question we ought to pause and consider is: what has been the cause of our stability? Americans are no different than any other humans around the globe, so it’s not us. We could credit the Constitution, but that didn’t magically appear out of a vacuum. The creators of that document did so from the perspective of a particular worldview, and we would not have gotten that document from any other. 
Those involved in framing our Constitution had a specifically Judeo-Christian worldview. No, not all of them were Christians, nor were they attempting to form a theocracy (in fact, it was because of their worldview that they didn’tform a theocracy). Their worldview provided them with an accurate understanding of human nature: humans are terribly flawed and require laws. However, did we mention that humans are terribly flawed? Therefore, those with power are also terribly flawed, and thus, checks must be placed on that power. As James Madison said, “But what is government itself, but the greatest of all reflections on human nature. If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary.” 

Because they knew the destructive nature of humans with ultimate power (aka, “government”), they placed “the chains of the Constitution,” on them. They did so, however, with the understanding that the citizens of the republic would be self-governing. This is a necessary component for freedom. As Benjamin Franklin said, “Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As nations become corrupt and vicious (stemming from the word “vice”), they have more need of masters.”

Yeah. Those “old, dead white guys,” as they are so often described, weren’t so dumb, huh? 

What we see going on today is the structure of our Judeo-Christian worldview—which no one notices any more because “it’s always been this way”—being used (or, rather, abused). At the same time, we are violently ripping out the foundation upon which we’ve been standing these 200+ years. We want the benefits of the Judeo-Christian worldview (e.g., liberty, peace, prosperity, etc.), but we want to be rid of the worldview itself (which is what our entire nation rests on). We don’t realize that thousands of years of history and philosophy went into the crafting of the two most profound and momentous political documents in the history of mankind: the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution.
To paraphrase G.K. Chesterton, before removing a fence, wisdom would suggest you look into why it was put there in the first place. Likewise, we foolishly think we can destroy our foundation and no harm will come to us as a result. Before you go back to hating people on Twitter today, perhaps we could take a moment to ponder what America will be like after we have torn her down brick by brick. Unless you’re a fan of less freedom, you may not like what you see. 
There is no substitute for what we have to do to rescue America. 

 

Wednesday, July 4, 2018

The 2018 LITD Independence Day post

In recent years, when preparing to write this post, the question before me has been whether or not my rhetorical device of referring to this country as "post-America" is still applicable.

Believe me, I understand that there's no arguing with the perspective that, in myriad undeniably significant ways, no human beings have ever had it better than Americans have it on July 4, 2018. Cell phones, laser surgery, economic opportunity, declining crime rates and all that.

But there's also no denying the extremely poor state of the nation's spiritual health. Pick your arena for citing examples: entertainment, education, law, "journalism." A nation in good shape would not have elected either its current president nor his immediate predecessor.

The polarization gets worse by the day. Any attempt to construct a chart of the fracturing is nearly impossibly complex. The days when the Right consisted merely of an Establishment and a conservative movement seem like a quaint and distant memory. We now have the intrusion of the Trump phenomenon, which has, along with itself, splintered the conservative movement into numerous shards. On the Left, the New York House-seat Democrat primary victory of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez over incumbent Joe Crowley crystallizes an even further leftward shift in a party that was already unrecognizably leftist when it catapulted an Alinskyite community organizer to its top rung in the previous decade.

Still, the forces of fealty to the Three Pillars of conservatism are not extinguished.

New to this site? Alright, Independence Day is as good a time as any for us to revisit the Three Pillars, so we're all on the same page. I'm not the first pundit to articulate them. In fact, the towering giant of our worldview, Ronald Reagan,  spoke of them.

But I've come up with my own formulation. I wanted to keep them devoid of shorthand. I was looking for ways to express them that would encompass any and all specific questions about the way human beings ought to organize themselves into livable societies, and I think I have.

They are as follows:

1.) Free-market economics, which begins with the premise that a good or service is worth what buyer and seller agree that it is worth - period. No other party has any business being involved in that agreement - certainly not government.

2.) An understanding that Western civilization has been a unique blessing to humankind. (Judeo-Christian morality, Greco-Roman model of representative democracy, the great scientific and artistic achievements.)


3.) A foreign policy based on what history tells us about human nature. This plays itself out as our allies knowing we have their backs, our adversaries respecting us, and our enemies fearing us.

Anyway, as I say, there is a swath of America that understands them and remains committed to seeing them upheld and implemented on the culture and policy levels. Despite the best efforts of the two other main groupings in post-America, that swath has not been extinguished.

In a post yesterday, I put that thusly:

It's interesting, isn't it? Trump lives rent-free inside the heads of enraged hard leftists, and those of us who, while applauding the good moves, particularly judicial appointments and deregulation, find him ideologically unmoored and loathsome on a character level, live rent-free inside the heads of the [Emerald] Robinson and [Kurt] Schlichter types.

Meanwhile, we just proceed according to our principles. To the two groups above - progressives and populists, for shorthand - our continued existence is something they dare not acknowledge.
This is encouraging particularly with regard to the understanding that the guidance provided by God's mighty hand is, as always, vital to this country continuing to exist in some recognizable form. Not many people do understand that anymore. But some do, and we're not going to be silenced or brainwashed.

Speaking of shorthand, here's a tidy way of putting that. There are still people in this country who will, upon reading aloud the Declaration of Independence, listening to the United States Marine Band rendition of the National Anthem, or the Mormon Tabernacle Choir's version of the Battle Hymn of the Republic today, be unable to refrain from openly weeping and trembling. The love of human freedom and gratitude to God for giving it to us burns hot within them.

That's how we know all is not lost.

All is not lost. Even if only as an idea, tattered from battle, like the flag Francis Scott Key saw from his jail-cell window, the United States of America lives.

God, as always, is up to something great in human history.

Happy Independence Day.



Saturday, February 10, 2018

One of those big-picture looks at how America came to its current juncture - crammed into a Townhall column

Paul Dreissen isn't a columnist whose stuff I read every time I see it. He tends to have a circumscribed range of focus: environmental issues. These are important, as the ample number of LITD posts in that category will attest, but on any given day, I may or may not have time to check out the latest on that front.

But his column today is worth everybody's time. I will say the contour of it is a little weird. Using his attendance of a recent jazz performance to riff off (pun intended) into a look at the unprecedented blessing to humankind the was this nation's founding, and how collectivism, particularly in its environmentalist form, has sullied the founders' vision seems a bit forced.

But once he gets going, he has important things to say:

What indeed was our Creator thinking, when he gathered those brilliant, classically educated farmers, merchants and tradesmen from all over Colonial America, giving them Divine Guidance to debate ideas and craft documents that declared independence from the then-most powerful nation on Earth, launched a novel, untested form of government – and birthed the bold notion that all men (and women) are created equal … at least as an ideal, at least eventually, at least after the long, bitter struggles of the Civil War and Abolition, Suffrage and Civil Rights Movements?

They didn’t stop there. The 1787 Constitution also launched the concept of federalism: the idea that a national government should legislate and rule only on national issues, but otherwise should leave individual states to innovate and test their own governing principles, for better or worse. They might devise brilliant solutions that are copied by all, or provide glaring examples of what not to do elsewhere.

Concerned about pure democracies and a tyranny of majorities, our Founding Fathers also established a separation of powers via three co-equal branches of government – and an Electoral College to prevent big urban areas from overwhelming sparsely populated rural and small town areas during presidential races. Five candidates have since received a majority of votes, but not electoral districts, and so lost their bids.
When was the last time you saw the essence of the United States of America so clearly articulated?

Then he - necessarily - gives us a case of the sads:

[We've been saddled with] government agencies and activist groups that ignored the enormous environmental progress America has made over the past four decades, and were demanding that we spend trillions of dollars on imaginary problems and for barely detectable (or even fabricated) benefits from further reductions in pollution – even substances that clearly are not pollutants: plant-fertilizing, crop-enhancing, planet-greening, life-giving carbon dioxide, for instance. 

And he reminds us that all the ways the jackboots would have us drastically alter our way of life would amount to a drop in the bucket in changing the numbers they profess to want to change:

 . . .the Energy Information Administration says fossil fuels will still provide 79% of US energy in 2050–globally too. Wind and solar remain too expensive, unreliable and land-intensive to power economies or give impoverished nations the living standards they dream of.

Meanwhile, the Obama EPA’s MAGGICC climate analysis model determined that even shutting down all US coal-fired power plants and drastically limiting the nation’s greenhouse gas emissions – at a cost of up to $39 billion per year – would prevent just 0.03 degrees F of manmade global warming by 2100, even assuming CO2 drives climate change, because the world will still be burning fossil fuels. In fact, all the damage and dire threats supposedly caused by greenhouse gases exist only in computer climate models.
And those models haven’t worked in the past, don’t work now and are unlikely to work in the foreseeable future, say scientists like William Happer and Anthony Sadar. That’s because they focus on CO2, ignore the most important atmospheric gas (water vapor) and can’t solve enough equations needed to accurately describe Earth’s climate. Relying on them to decide energy and economic policies is folly and fakery. 

He ends by not-altogether-gracefully tying it all back to the jazz concert. I guess it does work, in the sense that jazz is another one of those blessings to humankind that is originally and distinctly American.

And American things are good things.

Monday, July 3, 2017

Another Independence Day when prayer and grieving are more appropriate than celebration

Independence Day for the past few years has demonstrated what good advice it is to engage this fallen realm with the most modest of expectations. No worldly good thing, not even one of the two most special nations in human history, is going to provide any of us with unending blessings.

We still have the backdrop of material abundance that makes for counterarguments to the fact that America and the West generally are past the peak of their ability to enhance human life. It was the main counterargument put forth, usually by leftists but sometimes smart and principled people on the right who somehow amassed enough evidence to embrace a we've-never-had-it-so-good perspective, from the time that Western decline became obvious to all who chose to see. It was an argument that persisted during the Obama years, even as economic productivity ground to a halt, radical Islam rallied for a new era of menace, America's nation-state enemies, adversaries and rivals came to see it as an easy mark, and the culture's rot accelerated.

I didn't even bother to write a post explicitly reflecting on Independence Day last year. My posts from July 3 were entitled "They Smell Weakness - Today's Edition" (about a Russian frigate coming within 150 yards of the USS San Jacinto in the eastern Mediterranean) and "It's Because of Infantile Dweebs Like This That Jihadists Feel Emboldened" (about a collection of essays by Ohio State professors on that school's blog blaming the mass shooting at Orlando's Pulse nightclub on "toxic masculinity," ultranationalism" and "fetishization of weapons.") My July 4 entry was about Huma Abedin, who could well have been our current White House Chief of Staff, disposing of personal documents in a burn bag.

The fault lines are a little different now from a year ago, but not a great deal. The players are still the same. A hard left still pursuing the Great Leveling Project, a cadre of Donald Trump fans whose slavish devotion keeps them blind to his obvious unfitness for his position, a news, opinion and entertainment media world with its own culture of self-congratulation, a church seemingly unable to address any of this, and a handful of citizens preoccupied with the relationship between freedom and the need for God.

Yes, Donald Trump was elected president, giving the Republican Party control of the federal executive and legislative branches, as well as over half the nation's statehouses. Yes, Neil Gorsuch was appointed to the Supreme Court, and just this week it made a difference in two key decisions. Yes, the Keystone XL and Dakota access pipelines are going forward after years of obstruction for no reason rooted in reality, Nikki Haley is injecting urgently needed candor into proceedings at the UN, yes, Betsy DeVos is doing likewise at the Department of Education, and, yes, the employment picture is improving.

But none of this is sufficient to alter the conclusion that America has turned its back on God.

The notion that there can be anything other than two genders, a hard fact confirmed by everything from scripture to DNA tests, continues to gain ground. For all the positive official moves on the environmental front, such as pulling out of the Paris accord, municipal officials and scientific associations are determined to do all in their power to continue to abide by its utterly useless requirements. Universities continue their "privilege" indoctrination, even as they jettison the teaching of Milton and Shakespeare.

A few things are a little different this year. A media world and a president who deserve each other are locked in a cage match characterized by a mock beheading on one side, and a mock body slam on the other. The "Affordable" Care Act, which so entrenched the fiction that health care can somehow be a right that its repeal must be handled in such a way as to avoid forthrightly saying that it can't, may yet be dismantled.  The ISIS caliphate is in its death throes, even as its outposts in lands far from the Euphrates Valley grow in number and strength.

But in most important ways, it's the same trajectory as it has been. There is nothing less coarse about the culture. There is nothing less violent about inner cities. The family is even more an object of hate for the arbiters of what is left of our social architecture.

Society is so fractured, Black Lives Matter and the LBGT activist community can't abide by each other staging events. And then there's the right side of the spectrum. We have the likes of Kurt Schlichter calling Ben Sasse a wimp for taking a principled stand against the cringe-inducing Twitter habit of the president. (Chalk up another name on the list of pundits I used to admire but for whom my respect is rapidly dwindling.)

I'll read the Declaration aloud to my wife tomorrow morning, as I have for twenty-seven years, but more with the sense that I'm reading a blueprint for what could be tried among some people somewhere if they ever felt compelled.

This big wide continent sure would make a nice place for somebody to start a country predicated on the primacy of human freedom and dignity.




Saturday, April 29, 2017

Saturday roundup

This guy didn't even concern himself with the fact that everyone knows she ain't no pre-European American, such was the fervor with which he was pursuing his agenda:

WHY IS NBC LYING ABOUT ELIZABETH WARREN? In a story headlined Trump Again Derides Elizabeth Warren as ‘Pocahontas,’ NBC’s Daniel Arkin writes: “President Donald Trump returned to one of his most derogatory insults Friday, referring to Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren as “Pocahontas” — a jab at her Native American ancestry.”
Now I’m sure that Arkin knows that this isn’t a jab at her “Native American ancestry,” but at her fake Native American ancestry. So why pretend otherwise? To make Trump look bad. Which I guess explains why more people trust Trump than the media after 100 days.
After reading Mike Sabo's review of Thomas G. West's The Political Theory of the American Founding: Natural Rights, Public Policy and the Moral Conditions of Freedom, I want to read the book itself.

Here's how West systematizes the elements of what drove the Founders to approach the invention of a new basis for a nation-state the way they did:

West divides his book into three overarching sections: an overview of the founders’ political theory, an argument for why they thought government should inculcate citizen morality and virtue, and an extended examination of their views on property and economics. As he reasonably argues in the book’s introduction, before we can praise or condemn the founders, we must “first know” both “why the founders set up the regime they did” and “how their political order worked.”

All nation-states exist to protect something, but the founding of the United States of America was the first instance of using that concept to protect something truly universal:

 Natural rights are the inalienable liberties all human beings possess, not through government largesse, but by nature. Because “all men are created equal” in the sense “that there are no natural masters or natural slaves,” everyone has the natural liberty to order his life “without interference from other people.” Among these rights are the right to life, possessing and acquiring property, religious liberty, and to seek happiness—what West calls “the goal of human life.”
On the reverse side of rights are the duties all men have not to transcend the moral limits on the use of their rights. The founders called these natural limits the law of nature, or natural law. Natural law, which can be discovered through the faculty of reason, is “both the source of natural rights and a statement of our duties.” West argues that “natural liberty exists only within the moral limits of the law of nature.” Liberty, in other words, does not equal license.
Because all men are created equal, just government can only be founded on the unanimous consent of individuals who want to protect their rights, which are insecure outside of civil society. (The founders called the condition in which there is no common authority to protect against infringements of one’s rights the state of nature.) “The logic of the equality principle,” West contends, “necessarily leads to the right of the people to rule themselves in person or through elected representatives.” Consent, then, must be granted not only at the founding of a regime but also in the course of its operation, lest it degenerate into a tyranny.
And West, by way of Sabo, deftly dispels the notion that government promoting virtue somehow runs counter to the premise of liberty. Quite the contrary:

Against the view of scholars such as Thomas Pangle, Allan Bloom, and Harvey Mansfield, West contends that the founders were far from being concerned only with low bourgeois virtues, such as acquisitiveness, and comfortable self-preservation. In fact, they considered “virtue as a condition of freedom and a requirement of the laws of nature.”
Many public documents from the time spoke of the need for social and republican virtues within the populace such as justice (i.e., obeying the law), moderation, benevolence, temperance, industry, frugality, religious piety, and a responsibility among the people’s representatives to secure their good. In times of war, however, virtues of strength such as courage, leadership, bravery, vigor, and manly exertion are required. “Virtue is of concern to government not as an end in itself, but as a means to security and ultimately to happiness,” West concludes.
Opposed to the libertarian ethos that has consumed much of the Right, West argues forcefully that the project of sustaining our republic is not satisfied simply by getting government out of the way. The founders thought it was the duty of government (at least at the state level) to encourage virtue through public education, support for religious instruction, and a vast network of laws that discourage crime and promote stable families.
And to those who might be inclined to chime in with, "Aha! These much-venerated Founders were proponents of public education!", all one has to do is point out that current public education serves a purpose pretty much at odds with what they wanted to see it cultivate.

Then there is the matter of property rights, by which the Founders didn't just mean ownership, but also the chance to become an owner:

West also highlights an important but overlooked part of the founders’ theory of property rights: human beings have the right to possess and acquire property. They thought this important so that “the poor as well as the rich can benefit from property rights.” This stands in stark contrast to feudal ages in which serfs had virtually no prospects of climbing the ladder of opportunity and making their own way in life.
The ratcheted tensions in northwest Asia have Japan pretty skittish:

One of Tokyo's major subways systems says it shut down all lines for 10 minutes early Saturday after receiving warning of a North Korean missile launch.
Tokyo Metro official Hiroshi Takizawa says the temporary suspension affected 13,000 passengers.
Service was halted on all nine lines at 6:07 a.m. It resumed at 6:17 a.m. after it was clear there was no threat to Japan.
Takizawa says it was the first time service had been stopped in response to a missile launch. Train service is generally suspended in Japan immediately after large earthquakes. Tokyo Metro decided earlier this month to stop for missile launch warnings as well.
ESPN, like the Democrat party, is creating its own obsolescent with its leftward lurch.

Why isn't the "A"CA getting flat-out repealed in this era of Republican control of the federal legislative and executive branches? Byron York at the Washington Examiner contends that it's because somewhere between 25 and 50 Pub House members are scaredy-cats, afraid that they don't know how to articulate such a resolute position to the particular constituents in their districts.