Showing posts with label Pete Buttigieg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pete Buttigieg. Show all posts

Thursday, December 17, 2020

Two now-that-Biden's-election-is-official news items and LITD's take on them

 First up, Pete Buttigieg's nomination to be transportation secretary.

To begin with, nobody's claiming he's some kind of expert on transportation. It's pretty clear that this was a groom-the-next-generation-of-Democrat-up-and-comers move. Well, he did say that he enjoyed riding home from college on Amtrak and that he proposed to his fella in an airport terminal, so we have his generally favorable outlook about the transportation field as a plus of sorts.

The counter-argument is that cabinet-level positions are not the place for farm-team aspirants to the big leagues to hone their chops. You get a portfolio on that level, you're supposed to be ready to handle serious stuff. Oh, well, at least it's not a mega-serious post like Attorney General or National Security Advisor. 

What do we even have a Department of Transportation for, anyway? It strikes me as one of those federal behemoths like the Departments of Education, Health and Human Services, Commerce, Labor, Agriculture and Housing and Urban Development that is fertile ground for pointy-heads who want to implement programs without their germinating in that pesky legislative branch. James Madison is having seizures in his grave.

But in the Biden vision of things that's shaping up, Transportation is going to be a useful tool. Central planning is going to be back on steroids and climate stuff is one of the main areas of focus. Pete did have a record as a guy for whom central planning and climate stuff were turn-ons, and that's no doubt a factor in his being selected. 

He'll definitely be on the same page as John Kerry, who is chomping at the bit to get post-America all involved in the Great Reset, a vision that is incrementally taking shape at meetings of the UN, the World Economic Forum, the Business Roundtable and other organizations of similar odor. Oh, and if you needed further indication of how determined this bunch is to push the utter fiction the the global climate is in some kind of trouble necessitating massive government intrusion into the free market and people's freedom to chose the energy forms that suit them, Gina McCarthy is going to be the "climate czar." (I'm not clear as of yet how that differs from Kerry's lane as "climate envoy.")

The second new item is the dust-up over Joseph Epstein's Wall Street Journal op-ed about Jill Biden's PhD.

Joseph Epstein is an essayist and short story writer of uncommon depth and insight. He's frequently contributed short stories to Commentary that are among the best I've ever read. In 2004, he wrote an essay for The Weekly Standard entitled "The Perpetual Adolescent" that has rightly figured into our ongoing national conversation about the decline of our collective maturity. 

Is it possible, in hindsight, that he would have been better advised to hold off on writing the piece on Mrs. Biden in the form and at the time that he did? Sure. The way he starts out is definitely not lacking in attitude:

"Madame First Lady—Mrs. Biden—Jill—kiddo: a bit of advice on what may seem like a small but I think is a not unimportant matter," Joseph Epstein wrote. "Any chance you might drop the 'Dr.' before your name? 'Dr. Jill Biden' sounds and feels fraudulent, not to say a touch comic."

But the inevitable cases of the vapors exploded on the scene immediately. And of course, the charge of misogyny the main point of the outrage.

The back-and-forth goes on. I'm particularly impressed with Kyle Smith's take at National Review. Smith doesn't mince words, and they're words I resonate with. 

There's this tidbit regarding her motivation for getting the degree:

Insisting on being called “Doctor” when you don’t heal people is, among most holders of doctorates, seen as a gauche, silly, cringey ego trip. Consider “Dr.” Jill Biden, who doesn’t even hold a Ph.D. but rather a lesser Ed.D., something of a joke in the academic world. President-elect Joe Biden once explained that his wife sought the degree purely for status reasons: “She said, ‘I was so sick of the mail coming to Sen. and Mrs. Biden. I wanted to get mail addressed to Dr. and Sen. Biden.’ That’s the real reason she got her doctorate,” Joe Biden has said.


Smith has taken the time to actually read Mrs. Biden's dissertation. He has come away underwhelmed and then some:

Jill Biden’s dissertation is not an addition to the sum total of human knowledge. It is not a demonstration of expertise in its specific topic or its broad field. It is a gasping, wheezing, frail little Disney forest creature that begs you to notice the effort it makes to be the thing it is imitating while failing so pathetically that any witnesses to its ineptitude must feel compelled, out of manners alone, to drag it to the nearest podium and give it a participation trophy. Which is more or less what an Ed.D. is. It’s a degree that only deeply unimpressive people feel confers the honorific of “Doctor.” People who are actually smart understand that being in possession of a credential is no proof of intelligence.

My friends, I have read this document in its entirety and it is so equally lacking in rhetorical force, boldness of conception, and original research that it amounts to a triple null set, a vacuum inside a blank inside an abyss. If Ingmar Bergman were alive and hired to make a film about this paper, he would say, “I can’t do it, there’s so much emptiness even I cannot grasp it,” and it would sound so much worse in Swedish that suicide hotlines would have to hire extra staff. Gene Simmons has a better claim to be a Doctor of Love than Jill Biden to be a Doctor of Education; after all, Simmons has spent a lifetime demonstrating mastery of his field. As for Biden, she has spent a lot of time teaching remedial English to slow learners in community colleges. Which is like being a rock musician who’s in a bar band. That plays covers. At mixers. Held in assisted-living facilities. Mrs. Biden’s dissertation emits so much noxious methane the EPA should regulate it, Greta Thunberg should denounce it, and Hollywood celebrities should hold a telethon to draw awareness to its dangers.



The point of those who have troubled themselves to get into this matter (and, again, I'm not sure I would have) is that lowering of standards is a major problem in general in our culture. If we kow-tow to those who argue that just  because she spent a lot of time banging away on the keyboard her credential is the equal of anyone else's bearing the honorific "doctor," we further dilute our sense of rigor and make room for a notion of equality that winds up extolling the mediocre.

Taken together, these two items give us a taste of the tone we can expect in media treatment of this new regime. 

Those with viewpoints outside the parameters of that tone had best give some thought to withstanding the slings and arrows that are certainly headed their way.  

 


 






Friday, January 10, 2020

Friday roundup

Excellent piece by Rev. Dr. Carolyn Moore at the Wesleyan Covenant Association's website on why she responds to the looming UMC split with relief, even as she's dismayed at the death of courage that brought the denomination to this juncture:

Without context, the headlines in the national media might seem harsh and this plan to separate may come as a surprise. But for many who have been on this journey for years, this represents a significant and hopeful step forward. Most headlines last week led with the idea that the crux of the crisis is a disagreement over our sexual ethics, teachings on marriage, and the ordination of LBTQ+ clergy. I want to emphasize that the crisis in the UM Church does not rest on just these issues. Others agree. In a recent essay accurately entitled, “The Sad, Necessary Division of the United Methodist Church” David French writes:
“The secular media will cast the divide primarily in the terms it understands—as focused on “LGBT issues” – but that’s incomplete. The true fracturing point between Mainline and Evangelical churches is over the authority and interpretation of scripture. The debate over LGBT issues is a consequence of the underlying dispute, not its primary cause… there is a strain of Protestant Christianity that views the Bible as valuable but not infallible or inerrant. Evangelical Christians, by contrast, strongly dissent from that view.”
That seems an accurate statement to me. Our divide has been forming for years over multiple issues that are very real and very deep. They strike at the fundamentals of historical Christian orthodoxy. How we interpret scripture and relate to the person and work of Jesus Christ is at the headwaters of this crisis, but it is also important to note that our inability to hold one another accountable where we disagree only exacerbates the problem. When some of our leaders are unwilling to hold us accountable to the time-honored way we make decisions at our General Conferences, the result is a kind of disorder and dysfunction that is excruciating.
The hard reality we must admit today is that while we traditionalists have won votes at General Conference, we have not really held the line of orthodoxy within the UM Church. While we are thankful for the reaffirmation of our teachings, some of our American colleagues openly resist what we have reaffirmed. With no theological or ethical accountability and no will among many bishops to establish accountability, there is no line left to hold. Most of us – from across the theological divide – recognize we can no longer go on this way.
Some would implore us to stay in the current situation and keep voting for traditional values at General Conference, as if we might eventually wear down our progressive colleagues and compel them to leave. I have zero faith in that eventuality. A colleague in my conference who serves on the board of a progressive movement within the UM Church told me without blinking an eye, “We will never leave.” And I believe her. Why would she? With accountability on these matters gone – and it is – her approach is working to a degree; it is a functional response. So, we frustrate her sincerely held views on very important matters, and in return she and colleagues in her theological camp frustrate our sincerely held beliefs. This is not a healthy dynamic for a supposedly united church.
Friends, let’s support this protocol. Let’s get ourselves out of an Egypt filled with conflict and bitterness. The protocol might not be the promised land, but once we are out of the Egypt we are living in, we traditionalists can participate with the Holy Spirit in building a vital and fruitful movement that reflects our faith and the faith of our fathers. Our ground – the ground I want to be standing on – is on the other side of separation, where we can make choices from a place of strength, and without the anarchy we live in now.
It wasn't the first piece I'd ever encountered on the subject of guys who wear shorts in the dead of winter, but I was game when I saw this Atlantic article, hoping it would offer a fresh take, or a view of the matter that would take in all ages and demographics who so attire themselves.  Alas, I should have taken my cue from the title: "Why Some Kids Wear Shorts All Winter." Having thus limited the scope, we get a range of reasons that doesn't do much to shed real insight: attention-seeking, not wanting to appear wimpy, testing the limits of authority, and such. She even quotes a therapist who recommends that parents begin a conversation with shorts-clad boys thusly:

“Start with ‘I’m really curious,’ or ‘I’m wondering,’ or ‘I’ve noticed that you don’t like wearing [long pants] in the winter. Tell me more.’ What you might find is that it’s a sensory issue, that they say, ‘I don’t like the way the fabric feels against my skin,’” she said. “You might actually be able to work with that. You could be able to find something that would keep them warm but work for them a little bit better.”
Niskanen Center president Jerry Taylor posits that all this misses the obvious, something that might have surfaced if the Atlantic piece had included adult participation in the phenomenon:

Jerry Taylor

@jerry_jtaylor

Not just boys. Also men in DC. None of these explanations resonate. Per 
, we've simply raised people who want to be in pajamas all day and have zero sense of social decorum. Its like we have an entire adult world in day care.  


Conversation

From the Trump-occasionally-gets-one-right file: Today he announced that the National Environmental Policy Act will be getting modernized:



The proposed rule to bring NEPA into the 21st century would modernize environmental regulations without burdening “American workers, farmers, and families” by bringing new infrastructure projects to communities nationwide in an expedited fashion.
Per the White House, the proposed rule will:
  • Establish time limits of 2 years for completion of environmental impact statements and 1 year for completion of environmental assessments.
  • Specify page limits, promotes information sharing through modern technology, and better defines environmental effects and other key terms.
  • Reduce unnecessary burdens and delays for environmental reviews.
    Agencies would be allowed to establish procedures for adopting another agency’s determinations to increase efficiency.
  • Improve collaboration with state, local, and tribal governments.

 Better savor that. Those don't come along too often.

Now, how's this for an inflated sense of his own powers?





U.S. Cancer Death Rate Lowest In Recorded History! A lot of good news coming out of this Administration.
10:00 AM · Jan 9, 2020·Twitter for iPhone
But why wouldn't he say this kind of stuff, given the way his sycophants drool over him?


Lou Dobbs attacks America for not understanding we have an obligation to serve Donald Trump "It is a shame that this country which is benefitting so much from this president's leadership does not understand their obligations to this leader who is making it possible"

Mayor Pete didn't do his supposed moderate-Dem image any good by describing the shooting down (by an Iranian missile) of the Ukrainian airliner as "innocent civilians . . . caught in the middle of an unwanted and unnecessary tit for tat."


At The Imaginative Conservative, Hillsdale history professor Bradley Birzer reflects on the ancient uses of the term "The Word," or logos,  that may have informed the way St. John employs it at the beginning of his Gospel.















Saturday, August 10, 2019

Mayor Pete's idea of "faith outreach"

Well, well. He's hired a "faith outreach director."

Are you surprised to learn that she's a LBGT millennial and a former Episcopalian who left that denomination to become a Unitarian?

Here's how she sees her mission:

“The conversation about religion and politics has been dominated by one particular type of religion. ... It can be so much more,” she said. “I want to make sure the campaign is really reaching out to faiths that typically haven’t had much say in politics — Native American spirituality, Sikh spirituality, Bahais.”
I'd wager that there are a lot more black Democrats than there are practitioners of Native American or Sikh spirituality and Bahais of any party affiliation. And black Democrats are that party's demographic most likely to embrace sound Christian doctrine. And Buttigieg already polls abysmally among them. In South Bend, his name is mud among black citizens over a messy investigation into a police shooting.

I don't think he's helped himself with this move.

Wednesday, July 31, 2019

Night one of Dem debate two - some thoughts

Mind you, I didn't watch it - my band had a rehearsal last night - so the take I'm forming is based on those I've gleaned from news and opinion sites and Twitter so far today.

Some points of general consensus among those sites:

John Delaney and Tim Ryan were the two, relatively speaking, moderates, and the the radicals bullied them right out of the race.

Marianne Williamson, according to a few conservative pundits, flat-out won the thing.

I like this little insight from Buzzfeed's Ben Smith via Jim Geraghty at National Review:


She’s the political candidate for people who aren’t that into politics. Ben Smith of BuzzFeed mentioned that a Marianne Williamson staffer told him, “when she visits the networks, reporters and producers sneer at her, but the makeup artists always cry when they meet her.”
 Some noteworthy tweets about some of the others:

Erick Erickson on Mayor Pete:

Just a reminder that Pete Buttigieg is an Episcopalian, so his understanding of Christianity isn't very deep or serious.

Having progressive Christians lecture you about faith and scripture is like having communists tell you bread lines are good because it means people aren't starving.
7:29 AM - 31 Jul 2019

Jedidiah Bila on Fauxcahontas:


Warren is actually advocating that we publicly vow not to use a nuclear weapon unless another country uses it first. This is what she’s actually saying. Complete and total lunacy. Terrifying lunacy, actually.
7:22 PM - 30 Jul 2019

Katie Pavlich, also on Fauxcahontas:

As Elizabeth Warren closes the night with complaints about cost of college for students, just remember she was paid $400,000 to teach one class.
7:41 PM - 30 Jul 2019

Tonight ought to be interesting for fans of blood sport. Biden vs. Harris. I don't know that I'll check in with any consistency. No real excuse tonight, except that I don't want to get a case of the sads over the state of one of post-America's two major political parties.
 
 
 

Monday, July 22, 2019

Mayor Pete may find himself with an emptied-out South Bend police department

He doesn't exactly come off looking like a paragon of competence:

As South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg commands national attention with his media-savvy presidential bid, the firestorm back home over an officer-involved shooting shows no sign of settling soon -- with the mayor facing criticism not only from protesters but police who say his handling has crushed morale and risks a “mass exodus” from the force.
“Morale around here has been terrible. We do nothing,” one police officer, a 20-year veteran of the force, told Fox News. “We call ourselves firemen, we sit around in parking lots until we’re called and then we go to the call, because if you say or do something wrong, then you get hung.”
“At an all-time low,” another officer said of morale. “It’s been really demoralizing and hard to come to work lately.”
Officers requested not to be identified for this story in fear of retaliation by the mayor's administration. But they told Fox News that they know of multiple officers who are considering handing in their badges or taking retirement if eligible, in response to the mayor’s handling of the shooting.
“That's the big discussion ... is who's staying and who's going. I think you’re going to see a mass exodus, our administration is a joke,” one officer said.
South Bend Fraternal Order of Police (FOP) President Harvey Mills told Fox News that he has spoken to five or six officers who are “seriously” considering retiring or resigning because of the administration’s handling of the shooting. One officer told Fox News that he believes as many as 10 people will quit in the next year, and said he has also considered stepping away.
The latest spike of tension in the long-strained relationship between the mayor and the police department stems from the shooting death of a young black man, Eric Logan, by a white sergeant, Ryan O'Neill.

According to investigators, O’Neill was called to a report of someone breaking into cars and encountered Logan, who was allegedly carrying a knife. According to authorities, O'Neill shot Logan after he approached him with the knife and ignored repeated demands to drop it, the South Bend Tribune reported.

But O’Neill’s body camera was not on to confirm his account, and skeptics of the department's account have blasted city officials,  fueling a firestorm that repeatedly has pulled Buttigieg off the trail to deal with the crisis back home.
O’Neill resigned last week, with the FOP saying in a statement that “job related stress, the lawsuit, national media attention, and hateful things said on social media have been difficult for O’Neill and his young family.” 
There seems to be a reasonable explanation why O'Neill's body cam was not turned on (it didn't turn on automatically because his patrol car lights weren't on, and, with an armed car burglar coming at him with a knife, there wasn't a lot of time to turn it on manually. (Okay, Logan was allegedly carrying a knife, but O'Neill and the incident investigators understand how quickly a complete fabrication about such a significant detail would get them into trouble. Is there serious disputation about the knife?)

But Pete has to cast his lot with the narrative of some kind of general "systemic racism."

Buttigieg has claimed he has not taken sides, but amid angry protests back home, he has not challenged the narrative that the shooting is connected to police racism. At an NBC News-hosted presidential primary debate last month, Buttigieg described the shooting as “a black man ...killed by a white officer” and said he “could walk through all of the steps we took, from bias training to de-escalation, but it didn’t save the life of Eric Logan. And when I look into his mother’s eyes, I have to face that fact and nothing that I say will bring him back.”

“Until we move policing out from the shadow of systemic racism, whatever this particular incident teaches us, we will be left with the bigger problem of the fact that there is a wall of mistrust, put up one racist act at a time, not just what’s happened in the past, but from what’s happening around the country in the present,” he said.
It's that kind of stuff that is gong to leave Mayor Pete with a hollowed-out law enforcement agency:

. . . the repeated references to the "shadow" of racism in law enforcement (he said in June that "all police work and all of American life takes place in the shadow of racism") . . . particularly upset officers.

“To me, it’s like he kind of convicted Sgt. O’Neill before anything was even out, making comments like that,” one officer said. “It wasn’t based on the facts of what happened, because we don’t even have all the facts of what happened.”
“It’s like pouring gas on the fire,” the officer said.
"I feel like we're guilty until proven innocent," said another. 
One officer warned that it will significantly affect the hiring of good, new officers to replace them: “When you see the politics and the way police officers are treated by the media and by politicians, it’s like, why would anyone want to sign up to do this job right now?”
So he's going to make his city less safe, just to put himself on the side of one of the most egregious lies in the entire identity-politics hustle. 

Do we really want to find out how he'd manage this kind of thing on a national scale?



Monday, April 15, 2019

Mayor Pete's understanding of economic liberty is weak tea indeed

The American Enterprise Institute's James Pethokoukis makes some observations about a recent interview of Pete Butigieg by CNBC's John Harwood, and they're worth your considering, but I have my own, which I'll share momentarily.

First, the relevant part of the interview:

Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg, mayor of South Bend, Indiana, said some confusing things — or at least some things that confused me — in an interview with CNBC reporter John Harwood. Here is part of their exchange:
Buttigieg: … The economy is not some creature that just lumbers along on its own. It’s an interaction between private sector and public sector. And public sector policies, for basically as long as I’ve been alive, have been skewed in a direction that’s increasing inequality. And a lot of this is the consequence of what you might call the Reagan consensus. There was a period where even Democrats seemed to operate in this framework that assumes that the only thing you’d ever do with a tax is cut it. That those tax cuts were assumed to pay for themselves. The empirical collapse of that supply side consensus, I think, is one of the defining moments of this period that we’re living through.
Harwood: Why do you ascribe it to the Reagan consensus as opposed to technological change, globalization, movement of capital?
Buttigieg: Well, all of these forces interact. But none of these forces automatically have to make our society more unequal. If anything, globalization was supposed to create more equality among nations.
Harwood: Well actually it has created more equality in the world. It’s taken millions of people out of poverty.
Buttigieg: Sure, it’s lifted so many out of poverty. And by the way, there are ways that it can work for us at home, too. But again, we’re seeing a concentration of wealth and power that skews things in the opposite direction. The fundamental truth is, it turns out a rising tide does not lift all boats. Not on its own. Especially if some of the boats are sort of tethered to the ocean floor. And that’s the kind of pattern that we’ve been on.
As I say Pethokoukis then makes observations - six of them - that are incisive. I particularly resonated with number four:

Fourth, kudos to Harwood for correcting Buttigieg on the impact of globalization on inequality since Buttigieg is seemingly unaware that inequality between nations is experiencing an unprecedented decline. And as Harwood also correctly mentioned, market liberalization across the developing world — particularly China — has brought a billion humans out of extreme property.
But I wish Pethokoukis had addressed the even more fundamental problem with Buttigieg's thinking.

The economy is not primarily an "interaction between private sector and public sector." The private sector is the economy.  Even within the purview of what government puts in place - stuff that is the product of its proper Madisonian function, such as infrastructure, courts, law enforcement and the military - as well as all the stuff that most definitely is not the product of its proper Madisonian function, such as involvement in health care, agriculture and education, it is the private sector that provides the goods and services with which government does its thing. I see this in the countless county commissioners, county council, city council and board of works meetings I attend. To a large extent, they consist of approving contracts with privately owned organizations that do stuff and make stuff.

See, Mayor Pete, the public sector is - or at least ought to be - minuscule in comparison to the private sector. So minuscule that it ought to be folly to juxtapose them. The private sector is really just the sum total of millions of daily agreements made between people and organizations regarding the market value of millions of goods and services.

Which brings me to his trotting out of that business of tax cuts "paying for themselves." That's not the point, never has been, and never should be. The whole argument about government being too big is valid and one important reason why it's wrong to speak in such terms.

But it's not the primary reason why that's wrong. The primary reason is that, to repeat something that LITD says so often that I have to be careful that it doesn't turn into a formulaic talking point,

government ought to have to puke all over itself to justify taking the first penny from any of us, rich, middle-class or poor. 

There is a justification to be made for a small degree of taxation. See the above-enumerated proper functions under a Madisonian framework.

But that's it. The rest of the money you have ought to be yours and immune to government seizure.

Maybe being raised by a Marxist obscured this simple moral truth for Mayor Pete.

But maybe he can get schooled in the process of running for president.